Mile Post 370

Mile Post 370
Mile Post 370

Monday, July 1, 2019

Guest Post: Steven Greenhut, Orange County Register, via REASON Magazine=> Rail Transit Is a Dead End, but Social Planners Keep Pushing for More

Full Disclosure:  I'm a Railfan.  I like trains; Freight Trains, Passenger Trains, High Speed Rail, Light Rail, Narrow Gauge and especially Steam Trains.  I've volunteered at Railroad Museums, been a member of the National Railway Historical Society, bought tickets and ridden Excursion Trains, both steam and diesel powered, "Chased," photographed and made audio and video recordings of special trains.  I've ridden Steam and Diesel Trains on the Strasburg Railroad, Reading, Blue Mountain & Northern, Great Smokey Mountains Railroad, Western Maryland Scenic Railroad as well as in amusement parks, such as The Maggie Valley Railroad (long gone, since 1964?) and Tweetsie Railroad.  I've even chased and photographed the Ringling Brothers, Barnum and Bailey Circus Trains before they discontinued running the Circus Trains within the past 2 years.  But the idea of High-Speed Railroad and Commuter Railroads, both pushed by the Obama Administration, and the repercussions they bring, have soured me on both.

*********************************************************

Rail Transit Is a Dead End, but Social Planners Keep Pushing for More

Government planners do not understand markets, so they promote overly pricey projects that fail to meet our real-world transportation needs.

It has been around 15 years since Orange County tried to build a $1 billion light-rail system that would have gone from one suburban parking lot to another. It would have moved around half of 1 percent of the county's commuters. What I remember most about that incredibly shrinking Centerline was that while it was supposed to reduce congestion overall, it would actually have increased congestion along main thoroughfares.
That was my first up-close encounter with the Cult of Transit. There is nothing wrong with expanding bus service and building new rail lines—provided they actually enable people to get where they are going. However, urban planners' fixation on transit stems more from social engineering than transportation engineering. The latter develops projects that enable people to get from Point A to Point B. The former builds projects designed to change the public's behavior—prodding them into getting around in ways the planners believe is best.
If you've got time on your hands, peruse the details of virtually any road-funding bond measure and see how much of the new tax revenue goes to roads—and how much goes to bike lanes and other alternative transportation methods. I remember when Gov. Gray Davis was at a ribbon cutting for a stretch of the 210 freeway near San Bernardino. Commentators declared that after that opening, the era of road building was over. No wonder congestion has only gotten worse.







Despite the planning community's long-running embrace of transit, the latest data suggests the public prefers to get around in their cars and SUVs. Using statistics from the Federal Transit Administration, transportation expert Randal O'Toole summed up the data in The Hill: "Ridership declined in all of the nation's 38 largest urban areas. Transit systems in Austin, Boston, Charlotte, Cleveland, Miami, Milwaukee, Philadelphia, San Diego, and Tampa-St. Petersburg all suffered double-digit declines, with Austin losing 19.5 percent and Charlotte 15.4 percent despite being two of the fastest growing urban areas in the nation."
That's stunning given not only the $50 billion in subsidies that transit systems receive each year—but the Herculean attempts by urban planners to promote higher-density living through proscriptive land-use policies and tax subsidies, as O'Toole added. Transit systems work reasonably well in traditional cities such as New York and Chicago, but look at the design of California's metropolises. Commuting patterns go every which way, which makes it tough to develop an effective transit system to meet our needs.
Have you noticed how Californians move up and down the state?
They take Southwest Airlines, which offers low-cost, quick flights serving the major airports. Yet former Gov. Jerry Brown had focused his attention on building a $100-billion high-speed rail system that, if it ever is completed, will have ticket prices higher than airfares and will take nearly twice as long as flying to get from the Bay Area to Southern California. What is the point? The answer echoes my earlier point: Politicians and planners use public money to change how we live in pursuit of grandiose goals, such as slowing global warming. Easing cross-state travel is important, but if that were the primary goal, our leaders would consider a variety of practical—but boring—ideas, such as improving air service in hard-to-reach places such as Bakersfield, the Central Coast or Redding.
I think of my attempts to take transit to go from my exurb to downtown Sacramento. It would involve driving to a station 20 minutes away, paying for parking, buying a ticket and waiting for a train. It would take longer and cost almost as much as just driving downtown directly and parking. That train might make sense in the urban core, but not in the outlying areas, yet officials love to lecture us about our supposedly unsustainable reliance on driving.
This highlights the real problem with transit. Planners, not consumers, drive it. Real private enterprises—as opposed to firms receiving taxpayer-funded subsidies to build government-directed projects—would never build a rail system based on an "if we build it, they will come" model. They would build systems that meet customer needs rather than fulfill wishful fantasies.
Furthermore, O'Toole refers to our current approach as "big-box transit," which involves "moving people in 60-passenger buses, 450-passenger light-rail trains or 1,500-passenger heavy-rail or commuter-rail trains." This approach is the result of union pay scales and government's inefficient and centralized approach to transportation.
Opening up the marketplace could result in myriad, small-scale alternatives, similar to the way that Uber and Lyft have disrupted the taxi industry. Government planners only understand taxing and regulating and do not understand markets, so they promote overly pricey projects that fail to meet our real-world transportation needs. Until planners figure that out, expect those transit ridership numbers to keep falling.
This column was first published in the Orange County Register.
Steven Greenhut is Western region director for the R Street Institute. He was a Register editorial writer from 1998 to 2009. Write to him at sgreenhut@rstreet.org.
********************************************
I grew up in Charlotte, moving there in October of 1967.  It was a moderately small city.  There was no I-77 or I-85.  But as the area grew, Charlotte wanted to be like Atlanta.  The city leaders wanted the "Bright Lights and Big City" that was Atlanta.  Atlanta had a Pro Basketball Team, and Charlotte needed a Pro Basket Ball Team.  Then Charlotte got a Pro Basketball Team.  Atlanta had a Football Team, Charlotte needed a Pro Football Team.  Atlanta had a Regional Transit Authority and got Light Rail (MARTA).  Charlotte got a City Transit Service (CATS) and eventually would get a Light Rail System, but first there was the Charlotte Trolley.

The Charlotte Trolley was the initial attempt to get light rail.  First they claimed the original Southern Railway "R" Line that ran from the Charlotte C-D Yard next to North Davidson Street, under the 30th Street Bridge, down to just beyond Tyvola Road, where the new "R" Line met with the old line that ran through the city.

The Light Rail was first run with a Trolley from Greece, while an original Charlotte, Southern Utilities Trolley Car from the 1930s, that had been used as an apartment was restored.  It was still kind of a Museum Operation (you could ride from "the South End" Trolley station to one uptown and return, but you couldn't commute on it or get off anywhere else), with a cummins diesel trailer power car to provide electricity, before the catenary was put up) .  Then the City actually bought 3 Trolleys, that looked like the original 1930s Trolley.  I took my wife and kids to ride and we actually got to ride one when it was brand new.

Then Charlotte got a Light Rail Grant, with new Siemens M.U, cars, electrical sub-stations, a double tracked line from just north of Pineville, NC at I-485, all the way to the UNC Charlotte campus, with heavy rail and concrete cross ties, an overhead Catenary wire, Signals, a respectable Light Rail Facility (next to the Bus Maintenance Facility) on South Boulevard, and another on North Davidson Street, near the original Norfolk Southern Railroad terminus in Charlotte.  Where they hadn't appropriated the old "R" Line (from Woodlawn Road South, due to the cooking oil refinery (that was C & T Refinery and is now owned by Cargill) to Pineville, a parallel Double Tracked mainline was installed next to the freight stub line into the refinery.

The line from the Center of the City, South to Pineville passes through Dilworth, "the South End," Sedgefield, Collinswood, Madison Park, and Starmount neighborhoods as you move further South, before getting to Archdale, Sharon Lakes and into the north end of Pineville.  Most of these neighborhoods are demographically upper middle class, with Sedgefield having been the hottest piece of Real estate on the east coast.  But they were once low cost, low rent neighborhoods.  Apartments and Condominiums are growing up on South Boulevard, where there once we're businesses.  To say that this area (out to Starmount) has been gentrified is partially true.  But, with the coming of the Light Rail, many people who were moving into Charlotte from the Northeast and already were accustomed to taking the light rail or subway to work, this was marketed toward them and a hence fore unknown demand was made to order.

When the line to the northeast  to UNC Charlotte, via the NoDa (North Davidson Street) neighborhood was built, NoDa was getting going, but getting there was accomplished by going through the historic Belmont neighborhood (near Parkwood Avenue), which was barely starting to be gentrified the Plaza (Road) section near Sugar Creek Road was likewise still rough and only beginning gentrification.  But then it passed through the edge of Hidden Valley, a neighborhood that started out as white, quickly turned black and even more quickly developed a drug and gang problem.  A good part of the neighborhood is turning hispanic, but it's not being gentrified.  As the line passes out of the edge of Hidden Valley, you get more high end apartments, eventually passing the University Memorial Hospital (part of Atrium Health Care) and terminating at UNCC.

At the stations, it is announced to keep your electronics and personal property close to you, implying that they could be easily stolen.It's no wonder that the light rail ridership is off, with the new addition of the northeast section of the CATS LYNX Blue Line

But, what bothers me the most about the light rail is that the street traffic has been purposely slowed down, in order to "encourage drivers" to take the light rail train.  The speed limit on North Tryon Street, between the end of the I-85 exit to US 29 and Old Concord Road has been reduced from 45 MPH to 35 MPH.  And on the south end of the LYNX Blue Line between the New Bern Street and Scaleybark Road Stations, the light rail line crosses the southbound lanes of South Boulevard twice at grade in a 1/2 mile section.

So the LYNX Blue Line has been a real estate boon to developers in Charlotte, who built apartments and condominiums.  It will probably speed the gentrification along the North Davidson Street sections of the Belmont neighborhood and the northeast section  of the Plaza, before Eastway Drive and old Concord Road.  There is a 200 home development being built between the old Concord Road Station and the McCullough Drive Stations.  But traffic is getting worse and Hidden Valley won't gentrify any time soon.  I don't see ridership growing on the north end in my lifetime (about 25 - 30 more years).









The Greatest National Sin: Forgetting Your Purpose and Failure to Finish Your Job

I read an article from the great History Professor, Victor Davis Hanson, detailing the vision and actions that have made President Trump such a great President.   A friend suggested that we need someone to tell the public the story of Trump and his accomplishments.  I rebutted his assertion that we need someone to tell Trump’s story in the election of 2020.  I respectfully disagree.

The 2020 election isn’t and won’t be the problem for Trump or the nationalist Americans who voted for him:  He’s safe for the 2020 round of elections, because the American citizens who voted for him remember that a vast left wing conspiracy decided to stage a coup d'état and void the will of the people who elected him.  They haven’t forgotten that key factor - yet.  Much like Great Britain in World War II, our Churchillian Bulldog, Sir Winston Churchill (or maybe the late Sheriff Buford Pusser might be a better all-American example), Trump, although he doesn’t smoke a Cigar, nor does he drink to excess in public, is still in the midst of the incomplete, unfinished battle, where he calls out his enemies with Tweets.    

But, it’s only a matter of time, until those who elected him forget why they elected him.   It will happen when most of his work is done, the mission is nearly complete and the battle is seemingly won, at the end of his Constitutionally limited terms.  Just before the final nail is driven in the coffin containing the monster that came so close to killing us.   The danger of his mission will be forgotten and the course that has been mostly corrected.  Then the public will lose focus and the slow creeping slide toward socialism will rear its head with mediocre candidates (like George H. W. Bush, after Ronald Reagan) to continue to take us to our oblivion of a national perdition.  Having failed to find another leader with the same vision and stomach for the battle, to which he could pass the baton of leadership, Americans will forget his accomplishments, only to remember his “vile tweets,” uncouth and unbecoming behavior that is “beneath the dignity of the office.” They will forget that we chose him as our champion, specifically because he brought the fight (our fight) to our mutual enemy.

Our example here is Europe after World War II.  

  • Instead of unleashing Patton to finish the job and defeat Leninist Marxism, we just didn’t have the stomach for it.  So we throttled our real leaders and deposed  them (or killed - many  claim that the car wreck that paralyzed Patton and shortly thereafter took his life was planned).  This allowed a dying enemy to recuperate and return from the dead.  
  • Churchill was defeated, because he was a warrior, and England decided that the time for war was over and past.  We were civilized, and refused to finish the cruel job at hand.  
  • General Douglas McArthur tried again during the Korean War, only to be rebuffed and told to stand down.  He resigned his commission over the difference in opinion.  
And what did these decisions get us?  A Cold War and Germany, who now dominates the European Union economically, having decimated Great Britain’s economy.

The greatest “sin” any civilization can have is to forget and deny its greatness.  And the English speaking civilizations are ALL GUILTY of this infraction.  Our heroes are only remembered after they’ve expired and we notice we’re sliding down that slippery slope towards perdition.

Get ready.  In 2024, we start sliding toward oblivion again.


On Being a Red Neck

I often identify as a Red Neck.

Most people do not understand why and attribute it to my Southern, Scots-Irish Roots, similar to Jeff Foxworthy's definition as being "gloriously unsophisticated."  I'll plead "guilty as charged" to that comment, but it's an infinitesimally small part of my being a Red Neck.

Red Necks are also disparagingly considered as part of the "poor, rural, laboring class."  Guilty again.  I'm not too far removed from the farm as to forget how farmers live, spending their lives in the sun, often getting sun burned.  But farmers are famous for using everything until it can't be used any longer.  It's only then when they've used up every part of what they've purchased or grew and at that point, they "parted the item out," keeping what can be repurposed and scrapping the rest.  I've also never been blessed with an abundance on money.  It is stewardship, and yes, I'll plead guilty again.

But the term Red Neck is related to rebellion...Believe it or not, in China.  As my 9th grade (junior) high school history teacher related the story, during the Boxer Rebellion, those that rebelled against the authority identified each other by tying a Red Bandana around their necks during the fighting.  As they were routed in their rebellion, they wished to blend back into the crowd and took their bandanas off.  Little did they realize (at first) that the dye from the Bandana had stained their necks and could not be washed off.  The authorities simply rounded up the "Red Necked" citizens and executed them.  So, am I a rebel?  In many ways, yes.

What I've tried to choose in life is to me "more real,"instead of having more money.


Sunday, June 2, 2019

More Proof that Container Traffic is leaving the West Coast and Moving East, via the new Panamax Lane of the Panama Canal

In the May 29th digital issue of Railway Age, this was a headline:  

Plans underway for “largest single-terminal container facility in the western hemisphere”

image description
A Hapag Lloyd vessel with a capacity of 13,300 twenty-foot equivalent container units is worked at the Georgia Ports Authority Garden City Terminal in Savannah, Ga. (Georgia Ports Authority/Stephen B. Morton)
The St. Louis Regional Freightway and the Port of Savannah are forging a partnership to create a new connection between the St. Louis, Mo., region and what aims to be “the largest single-terminal container facility in the western hemisphere.”
To cut to the chase, Savannah, Georgia is the fourth largest container gateway behind the twin ports of Los Angeles and Long Beach California and New York/North (New) Jersey.  The Port of Savannah is now marketing itself and has identified St. Louis as the HUB with which it will start to serve as a Demand Center.  The Port of Savannah is betting (with good reasoning) that it can ship containers quicker and cheaper to St. Louis than can the Twin Ports of LA and Long Beach.  First the trip from Savannah to St. Louis is shorter than the trip from LA/Long Beach, California.  Second, the geographic impediments (Mountain Ranges and Rivers) it needs to cross are less of an obstacle from Savannah than from LA/Long Beach.  And third, It costs significantly less to unload containers in Savannah than iy does on the west Coast.  Savannah is planning to be the LARGEST INTERMODAL TERMINAL IN THE US BY 2020, which will make it less costly and require less time to ship intermodal containers from a ship docking in Savannah than anywhere else in the Western Hemisphere.
Quoting the article:  
John Trent, Senior Director of Strategic Operations and Safety at the Georgia Ports Authority, which owns and operates the Port of Savannah, talked about the new rail service—he said it would be an attractive alternative to shipping by rail from the West Coast to St. Louis. He cited research that revealed the cost to shippers using the new service would be $300 to $400 less for each container moved—and the total time in transit would be comparable. He added that the rail service would be consistent from Savannah, a distinct advantage over more traditional gateways.
“We offer a premium, lower-cost option and, in addition, we provide that consistency,” said Trent. “We believe we have a viable solution to not only support existing business in the St. Louis region, but also to grow business in the St. Louis region.”
Mary Lamie, Executive Director of the St. Louis Regional Freightway, and other St. Louis-area freight industry professionals are excited about the project.
“I cannot overstate the potential of this new partnership and the opportunities it can create to develop stronger links between our region’s world-class freight capabilities and national and global supply chains,” Lamie said.
Say good-bye to transcontinental Intermodal train service.  The only problems Savannah will have is the capacity of the railroads that serve the port.  And don't think that Mobile, New Orleans, Jacksonville, Miami, Port Arthur and Charleston (SC) aren't waiting and watching for a chance to step in, when the rail traffic from Savannah slows their ability to unload containers to St. Louis.
Now let's see which Marketing Hub Savannah targets next....

Thursday, May 30, 2019

George Orwell’s 1984 Meets Fast Food

George Orwell’s dystopian novel, 1984, introduced the world to Newspeak...the perfect way to say nothing, while appearing to say something profound or important.

The other day, my wife went by the local Bojangles’ restaurant franchise to get a breakfast biscuit and drink, while on her way to help her parents.  She hadn’t finished the drink when she got back home, and it showed up on the kitchen counter, before it was used up and trashed.  Here is a picture of the “newspeak” message that was found on the back of the cup, with a message designed to comfort/satisfy the "greeniacs" who live among us:



Did you read the message on the cup carefully?  It’s more than a little nebulous, designed to comfort the end user/buyer and relieve any guilt of purchasing and using a product that isn’t "green."  Would this message work for you?  

I have a few questions.  What constitutes 92% degradation?  I can shred the cup in a few minutes (Max).  Is turning the cup from a molded form into vermiculite a 92% degradation?  


This is Corporate Bull Shit to try to appease "the Greeniacs."  With what passes as education today, it might just work....
However, let's have a little remedial education , to enlighten those who might not have thought this process all through.  With any process, there is waste involved.  This occurs in nature and in manufacturing.  In running an internal combustion engine, there is waste heat, rejected to the air around us, and waste exhaust gases.  

In nature, there is waste when nuts are grown, as the shells are not edible.  When we eat, our bodies produce waste excrement.  Waste by definition cannot be used.  In some cases, it's harmful.  In nature, most waste bio-degrades, and is eventually reused.  With manufactured goods, we try to make stuff that can bio degrade and return to nature.  Sometimes it doesn't work.

There are always trade-offs in life:  Opportunities are missed, and other paths are chosen.  In the case of disposable drink cups, the choices are Paper, Plastic or Stryofoam.  Paper is probably the most difficult to make, because of the weight of the paper stock and the "waxing" that is applied to the paper to make it waterproof.  But it biodegrades much more completely than styrofoam.  The trade offs are the insulation factor of the styrofoam as compared to paper stock.  Styrofoam keeps drinks hotter or colder than paper can.  It requires less ice in a cold drink in. order to keep it cold.  

That isn't saying that "recycled styrofoam" doesn't have a use.  Ground up Styrofoam is turned into Vermiculite and added to potting soil to keep it from packing and allowing air to get into the soil keeping microbes healthy in the soil.

Plastic is the least biodegradable option at this time.

As citizens of this planet, we're called to be good stewards of the resources that we live with.  It's foolish and short-sighted to have the attitude that "the next generation can figure out what they'll use.  We're going to use what we have now, and waste our resources.  It's considered unethical for parents to leave their children with less than what they had.

So, we make our choices in life.  The choice is yours:  McDonalds, who uses very little if any styrofoam in its packaging, or maybe Bojangles that uses styrofoam or even Dunkin' Donuts that uses plastic.  Choose wisely, but don't sweat the choice.


Thursday, May 23, 2019

President Trump, the “Adult in the Room,” Cancels the Federal Grant for California High-Speed Rail

In my E-mail this morning, was this headline from the International Rail Journal Magazine:


Trump administration withdraws $US 1bn California high-speed grant

May 17, 2019
Written byKeith Barrow

CALIFORNIA is preparing to launch legal action against the US government after the Trump administration withdrew nearly $US 1bn in grant funding for the state’s high-speed rail programme.
{"rendered":"California-HS"}



So what did the State of California think would happen, with a Businessman and Builder, who’s made his living building construction projects, as President of the United States, when California decided to cancel its High Speed Rail project, for which a Federal Grant had already been issued?  

California applied for a Federal Grant to help pay for a High Speed Rail project from L. A. to San Francisco, during the Jerry Brown Gubernatorial Administration.  It was granted during the Obama Presidential Administration.  Once Gavin Newsome became Governor of the “Bear Republic,” he (correctly) decided that the State of California could not afford to pay to finish the project, with its projected costs spinning out of control, and announced its termination, leaving a partially constructed right-of-way in the Central Valley of California, from Merced to Bakersfield, going from “no where” to “no where.”  This violated the terms of the Federal Grant Contract, so the Trump Administration withdrew the grant, threatening to start collections on the amount of money already wasted on a project that that never met its goals, and likely will never host a railroad, to probably become an intrastate highway right-of-way(!).

Full disclosure:  I’m a railfan.  I like trains.  High-Speed Rail in California, connecting San Diego, Anaheim and Los Angeles with San Francisco and Sacramento would have been “cool,” and possibly even been the “seed” to extend High Speed Rail over the Siskiyou to Portland, Salem, Tacoma, Seattle and to the Canadian border near Vancouver, British Columbia.

HOWEVER, even as a railfan, I understood this project was doomed from the “planning stages,” simply because the California HSR had decided to try another route out of the Los Angeles Basin, instead of the tried and true route over the Tehachapi Pass (building a parallel line to the current Union Pacific/Burlington Northern-Santa Fe railroad line that’s been around for over 100+ years).  They were going to build a new route with la 16-mile tunnel, through the Coast (Mountain) Range and across the San Andreas Fault. Additionally, California NEVER managed the project.  Even today, the project does not yet have a route selected over the Pacheco Pass that would once again cross the Coastal (Mountain) Range and the San Andreas Fault a second time, in order to enter the (San Francisco) Bay Area through Gilroy, San José, and Millbrae into San Francisco.  And I consider the fault of this financial debacle to be laid directly at the feet of the Obama Administration, at the very least, for not to requiring AMTRAK to administer and lead the project to control the money that was spent.

The cynical tax payer that I am says “enough!”  With the American economy about to go into the toilet because of unrestrained spending, and with Social Security running out of money in the near future, we don't need to squander precious funds.

I look forward to California challenging the Federal Government in court over the termination of the grant.  Maybe California should have Silicon Valley corporations fund the completion of the project, even if it means changing the scope of the project and going to Elon Musk’s Boring Company and turning it into the world's first “Hyper-Loop” project.





Guest Post=> Selwyn Duke=> The American Thinker=> Taming the Bench: MAGA Means Ending Judicial Precedent